Union Group Logo

White Sauce vs Red Sauce: Which One Is Right for Your Pizza?

Author logo

Admin

6 October 2026

When ordering pizza, the choice of sauce is usually red or white. Red sauce is made with tomatoes, while white sauce contains no tomatoes and relies on ingredients such as cheese, olive oil, garlic, or cream.
 

Here are the differences between white and red pizza sauce.
 

ALSO READ: A Guide to Fettuccine: Classic Italian Pasta Made for Rich Flavors
 

The Origins of Red Pizza Sauce

 

Tomatoes arrived in Europe during the 1500s, brought back by explorers returning from Peru. At first, many Europeans avoided them because they were believed to be poisonous. This belief arose because the acid in tomatoes could leach lead from pewter plates, which were popular among the wealthy at the time.
 

That perception began to change in the 1700s, when people in Naples started spreading crushed tomatoes, olive oil, sea salt, and chopped garlic over flatbread. This practice gave rise to an early form of red-sauce pizza.
 

Classic red pizza sauce is still commonly made with Italian tomatoes. Many cooks choose canned tomatoes because they retain their flavor well and are easy to use.
 

The result is a sauce with fresh acidity that remains distinct even against the lightly charred crust of a Neapolitan pizza.
 

The Origins of White Pizza Sauce

 

White pizza, or pizza bianca, has a longer history than red-sauce pizza. Ancient Romans ate this style of flatbread by slicing it and serving it with cheese, bitter greens, or figs. Bakers also used it to test the temperature of their ovens.
 

The tradition of preparing pizza without tomatoes continues today. Roman-style pizzas, for example, often leave out tomatoes and use ingredients such as onions and olives instead.
 

Pizza without tomato sauce has long been part of Italian culinary tradition.
 

What Red Pizza Sauce Tastes Like

 

Red sauce offers fresh acidity with a touch of natural sweetness from ripe tomatoes. The acidity balances the savory richness and fat of cheese and meat, helping the pizza taste lighter even with generous toppings.
 

Red sauce also works well with herbs, mushrooms, bell peppers, and dried chili peppers.
 

Its vibrant color and pronounced aroma add to the pizza's overall appeal.
 

What White Pizza Sauce Tastes Like

 

White sauce delivers the richness of dairy, cheese, and garlic. In the United States, white pizza sauce is often based on Alfredo sauce made with Parmesan cheese, garlic, salt, pepper, and milk.
 

Italian versions may use herbs, mozzarella, and olive oil. Garlic oil is frequently a key ingredient, while the remaining components are widely used.
 

Without the acidity of tomatoes, each topping becomes more prominent. Ingredients such as mushrooms, truffles, eggs, and aged cheese take center stage against a white-sauce base.
 

Toppings for Red-Sauce Pizza

 

· Boldly seasoned meats such as pepperoni, beef sausage, or spicy salami.
· Crisp vegetables such as onions and bell peppers.
· Fresh cheeses such as mozzarella or burrata.
· Chili oil and dried chili peppers.
 

Toppings for White-Sauce Pizza

 

· Mushrooms, from mixed varieties to porcini.
· Black truffles or white truffle oil.
· Mozzarella, fontina, taleggio, and gorgonzola.
· Eggs, whether scrambled or served with the yolk intact.
· Cured meats such as Parma ham, paired with fresh arugula.
 

Red and White Sauce Pizza at Caffè Milano

 

Every pizza at Caffè Milano is baked in a traditional wood-fired oven. We use hand-stretched dough and carefully select premium ingredients.
 

Under the direction of Chef Luca Pezzera, our menu reflects the authentic flavors of Milan and Northern Italy.
 

1. Red-Sauce Pizza Selections

 

· Margherita: A simple Italian classic featuring mozzarella, fresh basil leaves, and extra virgin olive oil.
· Carne: A meat lover's selection topped with beef sausage, beef pepperoni, and Bolognese sauce over a base of tomato sauce and mozzarella.
· Pepperoni: The classic combination of mozzarella and sliced beef pepperoni.
· Diavola (Exclusive to PIK Avenue): A spicy combination of soppressata sausage, dried chili peppers, and mozzarella.
· Pork Belly (Exclusive to Grand Indonesia): Tomato sauce and mozzarella topped with sautéed garlicky kale, crispy roasted pork belly, and chili oil.
 

2. White-Sauce Pizza Selections

 

· Funghi: A combination of mixed mushrooms, thyme, Parmesan sauce, mozzarella, chives, and fresh parsley.
· Quattro Formaggi: A cheese lover's selection featuring mozzarella, fontina, taleggio, and gorgonzola.
· Burrata: White sauce with basil and oregano, topped with a whole ball of soft, creamy burrata.
· US Prime Roast Beef: Premium US Prime roast beef with Parmigiano Reggiano, mozzarella, mixed mushrooms, and aromatic white truffle oil.
· Tartufo Nero (Exclusive to PIK Avenue): A premium combination of authentic Alba black truffle, mozzarella, fontina, and soft scrambled eggs.
· Nduja, Ricotta, and Caramelized Onion (Exclusive to Grand Indonesia): Creamy 'nduja, a spicy Italian pork sausage, with mozzarella, soft ricotta, sweet caramelized onions, and chili oil.
 

ALSO READ: Exploring Trattorias in Jakarta: Authentic Flavors to Savor
 

Try Red- and White-Sauce Pizza at Caffè Milano!

 

Caffè Milano serves red and white sauce pizzas, handmade pasta, and a curated selection of Italian wines and cocktails. 
 

Our place is warm and elegant, yet the relaxed atmosphere makes it a perfect destination for lunch, dinner, date night, or a family gathering.
 

Make a reservation at Caffè Milano PIK Avenue in Jakarta Utara or Caffè Milano Grand Indonesia in Jakarta Pusat.

U+ Rewards

WHAT IS U+ REWARDS?

U+Rewards is The Union Group’s exclusive loyalty program. Start earning points now and get exclusive privileges at all The Union Group establishments.

Download on App StoreGet it on Google Play
U+ Rewards